The short answer
Buy the Ninja Luxe Cafe if your household drinks espresso, drip coffee and cold brew and wants weight-based dosing and assisted tamping. Buy the Barista Express if you want a focused espresso machine and prefer to learn dosing, tamping and milk by hand.
Side by side
Scroll the table sideways to see every column.
Quick picks
The answer first. Tap any row to jump to the full reasoning for that pick.
1. Choose this for espresso focus
Breville Barista Express
Mid tier · The all-in-one: espresso machine with a conical burr grinder built into the case.
A built-in grinder and PID temperature, and nothing it does not need.
The Barista Express pairs a 54 mm stainless portafilter with an integrated conical burr grinder listed at 16 settings, heated by a PID-controlled thermocoil at 200 F.
It does one job - espresso and milk drinks - and leaves dosing, tamping and milk to you, which is how you learn.
Its grinder doses by time, which drifts as beans age and change density; weighing the dose fixes that.
It is a simpler machine than the Ninja, with fewer functions to learn and clean.
Specification
- Portafilter
- 54 mm stainless
- Grinder
- Integrated conical burr, 16 settings
- Heating
- Thermocoil, 200 F, PID controlled
- Footprint
- 15.9 x 13.1 x 12.4 in
What it does well
- One box, one price, one plug - nothing else to buy
- PID temperature control at this level is not a given
- Enormous owner base, so parts and answers are easy to find
Where it gives ground
- 16 grind settings is coarse resolution for espresso dialing
- The built-in grinder is the weakest component and cannot be upgraded
- Wide footprint for a single-boiler machine
Skip it if
Skip it if you also want drip coffee or cold brew from the same machine. That is the Ninja's argument - see the full review.
2. Choose this for one machine that does everything
Ninja Luxe Cafe Premier ES601
Upper-mid tier · A 3-in-1 espresso, drip coffee and cold brew machine with a built-in grinder and scale.
Espresso, drip coffee and cold brew, with a built-in scale and an assisted tamper.
The Luxe Cafe Premier is a 3-in-1: it pulls espresso, brews drip-style coffee and makes rapid cold brew from one machine.
Its built-in burr grinder has 25 settings, and Ninja's barista assistance recommends a grind size. A built-in scale weighs the ground coffee, so dosing is by weight rather than time.
An assisted tamper and a hands-free milk frothing system take two more variables out of the process.
It comes with a portafilter and three baskets - single, double and Luxe - plus a funnel and a froth jug with an integrated whisk.
Specification
- Drinks
- Espresso, drip-style coffee and rapid cold brew
- Grinder
- Built-in burr grinder, 25 settings, with grind-size recommendations
- Dosing
- Built-in scale for weight-based dosing
- Tamping
- Assisted tamper
- Milk
- Hands-free frothing, froth jug with integrated whisk
- Baskets
- Single, double and Luxe
What it does well
- One machine covers espresso, drip coffee and cold brew
- Doses by weight rather than time, which removes a common source of drift
- Assisted tamping and hands-free milk take more variables out
Where it gives ground
- A large machine, because it does three jobs
- The built-in grinder cannot be upgraded
- More functions means more to learn and more to clean
Skip it if
Skip it if you only drink espresso. You would be paying for drip and cold brew you will not use.
Weight against time
A timed grinder delivers whatever a set number of seconds produces, and that weight drifts as beans age. A built-in scale doses by weight, which is how baristas measure anyway. It is the Ninja's most useful espresso feature.
Barista Express owners get the same result by weighing with a separate scale - see coffee scales for espresso.